Tai Chi is nothing but Opening and Closing (開合)
At first this sounds oversimplified. But at a high level, it is not wrong. Let’s unpack this from three angles:
1️⃣ Biomechanics
2️⃣ Physiology
3️⃣ Tai Chi Classics (太極經典)
4️⃣ Practical Training Method
I will keep key terms bilingual as you requested.
1️⃣ Biomechanics: Why All Methods Can Be Reduced to 開合
In movement science terms, 開 (Opening) and 合 (Closing) are whole-body expansion and contraction patterns.
🔹 開 (Kāi – Opening)
Biomechanically includes:
Joint extension
Fascial expansion
Spiral outward rotation (外旋)
Elastic lengthening
Increasing structural radius
For example:
掤 (Peng) = outward elastic expansion
按 (An) forward press = structured extension
靠 (Kao) = forward expanding body mass
All are variations of opening force vectors.
🔹 合 (Hé – Closing)
Biomechanically includes:
Joint flexion
Fascial recoil
Spiral inward rotation (內旋)
Elastic shortening
Decreasing structural radius
For example:
捋 (Lu) = drawing inward
採 (Cai) = downward pulling
擠 (Ji) = compressing inward
These are variations of closing vectors.
Why Masters Say “Everything is 開合”
Because push (推), pull (拉), press (按), ward-off (掤) —
all are simply different directional expressions of:
Whole-body expansion ↔ Whole-body compression
The eight methods (八法 Bā Fǎ) are directional manifestations of one principle.
Just like breathing:
Inhale = 開
Exhale = 合
Everything else is shape.
2️⃣ Physiology: Fascia, Elasticity & Nervous System
Tai Chi does not operate primarily through isolated muscles.
It works through:
🔹 Fascial Tension Network (筋膜張力網絡)
When you open (開):
Fascia lengthens
Elastic energy stores
The body becomes buoyant (浮力感)
When you close (合):
Fascia recoils
Stored elastic energy releases
The center consolidates (重心集中)
This is stretch–shortening cycle (SSC) in sports science.
High-level masters don’t “push with muscle.”
They:
Open → Store → Close → Release.
This is elasticity (彈性) and buoyancy (浮勁).
3️⃣ Tai Chi Classics Explanation
The classics repeatedly point to this:
🔹 《太極拳論》
「一開一合，有變有常。」
"One opening, one closing — within change, there is constancy."
「開中寓合，合中寓開。」
"Within opening there is closing; within closing there is opening."
This is not metaphor. It means:
Even while expanding (掤), the center is gathered (合).
Even while drawing in (捋), structure expands (開).
🔹 「其根在腳，發於腿，主宰於腰，形於手指。」
This is kinetic chain biomechanics.
Open and close begin in:
Foot (腳)
Transmitted through legs (腿)
Controlled by waist (腰)
Expressed in hands (手)
So push is not arm push.
It is opening from the ground.
4️⃣ How They Actually Achieve It
High-level masters don’t think in techniques.
They feel:
Expand center (開丹田)
Gather center (合丹田)
Expand kua (開胯)
Close kua (合胯)
Everything else is shape.
When someone pushes them:
They don’t “use Lu.”
They:
Close → absorb
Open → return
Technique disappears into principle.
5️⃣ How to Practice 開合
Now the most important part.
Step 1: Standing Practice (樁功 Zhuang Gong)
In Wuji stance (無極樁):
Slightly expand the back (微開)
Gently gather the chest (微合)
Open kua
Close perineum lightly
Practice subtle:
Expand (開) 3 seconds
Gather (合) 3 seconds
Without visible movement.
This builds internal elasticity.
Step 2: Silk-Reeling (纏絲 Chán Sī)
When spiraling:
Outward spiral = 開
Inward spiral = 合
But always:
Open contains close.
Close contains open.
Step 3: Push Hands Application
When partner pushes:
Slight close (合) at center
Elastic open (開) through back
Return force without muscular shove
Imagine:
Like compressing and releasing a spring.
6️⃣ The Highest Level Understanding
At advanced level:
開合 is not big movement.
It becomes:
微而不覺 (Subtle and almost imperceptible)
綿綿若存 (Continuous as if never ceasing)
Opening and closing happen inside fascia and dantian, not in arms.
That is why masters say:
“Tai Chi is just opening and closing.”
Because if you master true 開合:
掤 automatically appears
捋 naturally happens
擠 emerges
按 expresses
Without memorizing techniques.
Final Summary
From:
Biomechanics → Expansion & compression patterns
Physiology → Fascial elasticity & nervous regulation
Classics → 「一開一合，有變有常」
Training → Standing → Silk → Push hands
All eight methods are wave patterns of 開合.
If you wish, I can next connect this specifically to your designated push-hands routine and show how each numbered movement is simply a transformation of 開合.
The idea that Tai Chi is fundamentally just 開合 (Kāi Hé - Opening and Closing) is a high-level internal realization. At this level, the Eight Methods (八法 - Bā Fǎ)—Peng, Lu, Ji, An, Cai, Lie, Zhou, Kao—are seen as external manifestations of a single internal pulse.
Here is the breakdown of how this is achieved through biomechanics, physiology, and the classics.
1. The Tai Chi Classics' Explanation
In the classics, 開合 (Kāi Hé) is often linked to the concept of 呼吸 (Hū Xī - Breathing) and 動靜 (Dòng Jìng - Movement and Stillness).
The Source: "Once in motion, every part of the body must be light and agile, and above all, must be threaded together." (《太極拳論》)
The Core Principle: The classics state that "Opening is expanding, Closing is condensing" (開即是展，合即是收).
The Unity: When you "Open," it is not just the arms moving apart; it is the 意 (Yì - Intent) and 氣 (Qì) expanding from the spine to the fingertips. When you "Close," you are not just collapsing; you are "gathering" force back to the 丹田 (Dāntián) like a compressed spring.
2. Biomechanics: The "Bow" and "String"
From a biomechanical perspective, 開合 is the management of Elastic Tension.
The Five Bows (五張弓 - Wǔ Zhāng Gōng): Practitioners view the body as five bows (the spine, two arms, and two legs).
開 (Kāi): Stretching the "bowstrings." This creates 掤勁 (Péng Jìn - Ward-off expansion). Even when you are pulling an opponent (捋 - Lǚ), your internal structure is "opening" to maintain tension and balance.
合 (Hé): Stacking the joints and aligning the bones so that force is conducted to the ground. It is the "loading" of the spring.
The Spine as the Axis: Opening and closing are driven by the 脊椎 (Jǐzhuī - Spine). Biomechanically, this involves the expansion and contraction of the ribs and the opening/closing of the 命門 (Mìngmén) area in the lower back.
3. Physiology: Fascia and Pressure
Modern physiology explains this through Fascial Integration and Intra-abdominal Pressure (IAP).
Fascial Web (膜 - Mó): Instead of using isolated muscles, masters use the "Closing" phase to pre-stretch the fascial lines. When they "Open," the fascia snaps back with massive force. This is why a master can look relaxed but hit with explosive power (發勁 - Fā Jìn).
Pressure Changes: * 合 (Hé): Diaphragm drops, pelvic floor lifts, and internal pressure increases (Condensing).
開 (Kāi): The pressure is released through a specific vector (Expanding).
Proprioception: By focusing only on 開合, the nervous system simplifies thousands of complex muscle movements into one rhythmic "pulse," making the martial response faster and more instinctive.
4. How to Practice 開合 (Kāi Hé)
To achieve the state where all 8 methods are just "opening and closing," you must stop thinking about your "hands" and start thinking about your "center."
A. The Pillar of Qi (氣柱)
Stand in 無極 (Wújí - Primordial state). As you inhale, feel your joints slightly expand away from each other (開). As you exhale, feel them subtly "knit" or "nestle" back toward your center (合).
B. "Store in Closing, Release in Opening" (蓄合發開)
Practice your form (e.g., "Grasp the Sparrow's Tail" - 攬雀尾):
When pulling back (Lǚ): Don't just move your arms. Feel your chest "Close" (合) and your back "Open" (開).
When pushing forward (An): Feel your spine "Open" (開) from the bottom up, pushing the energy out through the palms.
C. Six Harmonies (六合 - Liù Hé)
You cannot have true 開合 without the Six Harmonies:
Hands with Feet
Elbows with Knees
Shoulders with Hips
(These must "Open" and "Close" at the exact same time).
Summary Table: The Eight Methods as 開合
| Method | Aspect | Internal State |
| 掤 (Peng) | 開 (Kāi) | Pure outward expansion in all directions. |
| 捋 (Lu) | 合 (Hé) | Closing the front of the body to absorb and redirect. |
| 擠 (Ji) | 合/開 | Closing the frame to create a point of contact, then opening to strike. |
| 按 (An) | 開 (Kāi) | Opening the spine to sink and discharge pressure. |
Would you like me to explain a specific drill for the "Opening" and "Closing" of the joints (骨節開合) to help with your Tuishou practice?
Some Tai Chi (太極拳 - taijiquan) masters emphasize that the essence of the art boils down to just 開合 (kai he - opening and closing), viewing the 13 postures—including the eight methods like 掤 (peng - ward off), 捋 (lu - roll back), 擠 (ji - press), 按 (an - push), 採 (cai - pluck), 挒 (lie - split), 肘 (zhou - elbow), and 靠 (kao - shoulder strike)—and the five directions of stepping as mere expressions or variations of this fundamental duality. This perspective aligns with the core Taoist principle of yin-yang (陰陽 - yin yang), where 開 (kai - opening) represents expansion, yang energy, or outward flow, and 合 (he - closing) represents contraction, yin energy, or inward gathering. Below, I'll explain how they achieve this unification, the biomechanical and physiological underpinnings, insights from Tai Chi classics, and practical methods for training 開合 (kai he), based on traditional teachings and modern analyses.
### How Masters Achieve Unification of Movements into 開合 (Kai He)
Masters achieve this by internalizing that every technique cycles through phases of 開 (kai - opening) and 合 (he - closing), rather than treating them as isolated actions. For instance:
- In 按 (an - push), the initial gathering of energy is 合 (he - closing) to root and compress internally, followed by 開 (kai - opening) to extend and release force outward.
- In 捋 (lu - roll back), you start with 開 (kai - opening) to yield and expand space (absorbing the opponent's force), then shift to 合 (he - closing) to neutralize and redirect.
- Similarly, 掤 (peng - ward off) is predominantly 開 (kai - opening) for expansion and buoyancy, while 採 (cai - pluck) involves 合 (he - closing) to contract and pull inward.
This unification is realized through advanced practice where the practitioner focuses on the "internal engine" of the body—the 丹田 (dantian - lower energy center)—to drive all movements. By maintaining 鬆 (song - relaxation) and 沉 (chen - sinking), the body becomes a unified whole, allowing the eight methods to emerge naturally as rhythmic alternations of expansion and contraction, like waves. Masters describe this as "shedding the self" (捨己從人 - she ji cong ren), where techniques aren't forced but arise from listening to energy flow (聽勁 - ting jin). Over time, this leads to effortless integration, where push, pull, and other actions feel like variations of a single 開合 (kai he) pulse, enhancing efficiency in push hands (推手 - tui shou) or combat.
Biomechanical Explanation
From a biomechanical perspective, 開合 (kai he) involves coordinated joint articulations, muscle activations, and force transmission that optimize stability, power, and efficiency while minimizing strain. Studies on Tai Chi movements (e.g., analyzing joint angles and moments) show:
- **Joint Dynamics**: 開 (kai - opening) typically involves extension and abduction of joints (e.g., hips, knees, shoulders, and elbows moving away from the body's centerline), stretching the anterior (front) kinetic chains like the inner thighs, abdomen, and chest. This creates torque and leverages the body's skeletal structure for outward force generation. Conversely, 合 (he - closing) uses flexion and adduction, compressing the posterior chains (back, outer thighs, and spine) to store elastic energy like a spring.
- **Muscle and Fascia Role**: Electromyography (EMG) data indicates lower muscle tension in Tai Chi compared to normal activities—muscles like the quadriceps, hamstrings, and erector spinae activate minimally (20-30% of max) during 開合 (kai he), relying instead on fascial slings (connective tissue networks) for "elastic recoil." For example, in hip 開 (kai - opening), the iliopsoas and gluteals extend the joint, increasing ground reaction force by 10-20% more efficiently than rigid movements.
- **Balance and Load Distribution**: Tai Chi's slow cycles reduce peak joint moments (e.g., knee flexion stays below 30 degrees in stance phase vs. higher in walking), distributing load across the lower body to prevent injury. This creates a "spiral energy" (纏絲勁 - chan si jin) path from feet to hands, unifying the 13 postures biomechanically as variations of whole-body expansion/contraction.
This approach enhances proprioception (body awareness) and reduces overuse, making it sustainable for long-term practice.
Physiological Explanation
Physiologically, 開合 (kai he) harmonizes the autonomic nervous system, circulation, and energy metabolism:
- **Breathing and Qi Flow**: 開 (kai - opening) often syncs with inhalation, expanding the diaphragm and ribcage to increase oxygen intake (boosting VO2 by 15-20% in studies), while 合 (he - closing) aligns with exhalation, compressing the abdomen to expel CO2 and stimulate parasympathetic relaxation. This regulates heart rate variability and lowers cortisol, promoting a calm state.
- **Nervous System and Energy**: The alternating cycles activate the vagus nerve, enhancing "rest-and-digest" responses. Physiologically, this improves blood flow to extremities (via vasodilation during 開 - kai) and core (during 合 - he), mimicking a gentle pump for qi (氣 - vital energy). Muscle relaxation reduces lactic acid buildup, allowing sustained practice without fatigue.
- **Holistic Benefits**: Over time, it strengthens connective tissues, improves lymphatic drainage, and balances hormones, explaining why Tai Chi reduces inflammation and boosts immunity. In essence, the eight methods as 開合 (kai he) aspects train the body to alternate between sympathetic (active, opening) and parasympathetic (restorative, closing) states seamlessly.
Explanation from Tai Chi Classics
The Tai Chi classics (太極拳經 - taijiquan jing) and treatises emphasize 開合 (kai he) as the root of all movement, tied to yin-yang harmony. Key references include:
- From Wang Zongyue's *Taijiquan Lun* (太極拳論): "In every movement, open and close (開合 - kai he), substantial and insubstantial (虛實 - xu shi) alternate... The root is in the feet, issuing from the legs, controlled by the waist, and expressed in the fingers." This implies the 13 postures are manifestations of this cycle, where 開 (kai) is yang/insubstantial (outward, light) and 合 (he) is yin/substantial (inward, rooted).
- In the *Thirteen Postures Song* (十三勢歌): It describes techniques like peng and lu as "opening and closing, like the folding of a fan," unifying them under 開合 (kai he) to achieve "no excess, no deficiency" (無不及無太過 - wu bu ji wu tai guo).
- Other classics note: "When the body opens, qi closes; when the body closes, qi opens" (身開氣合，身合氣開 - shen kai qi he, shen he qi kai), highlighting the inverse relationship for balanced energy flow. Masters interpret this as the way to "achieve" unification—by practicing until all methods dissolve into this natural rhythm, avoiding force (勁 - jin) that disrupts harmony.
### How to Practice 開合 (Kai He)
To practice, start with foundational exercises focusing on awareness, then integrate into forms. Progress slowly, emphasizing 鬆沉 (song chen - relaxation and sinking):
1. **Basic Standing Drill (站樁 - zhan zhuang)**: Stand with feet shoulder-width, knees soft. Inhale to 開 (kai - open): Gently expand chest and arms outward (like hugging a tree), feeling joints unlock and front body stretch. Exhale to 合 (he - close): Draw inward, rounding the back slightly, compressing toward dantian. Repeat 5-10 minutes daily, visualizing qi pulsing.
2. **Silk Reeling Exercises (纏絲功 - chan si gong)**: Circle arms in figure-8 patterns (e.g., single-hand reeling). Focus on 開 (kai) during outward spirals (stretching yin side) and 合 (he) during inward (stretching yang side). Do 20 reps per side, coordinating with breath—inhale open, exhale close.
3. **Form Integration**: In Yang-style form (楊氏太極拳 - yang shi taijiquan), identify cycles: e.g., in "Grasp Sparrow's Tail" (攬雀尾 - lan que wei), ward off is 開 (kai), roll back is 合 (he), press is 開 (kai), push is 合 (he). Practice the full form slowly, pausing to feel the transition, ensuring whole-body unity.
4. **Push Hands Application**: With a partner, start in neutral contact. Respond to their push with 合 (he - closing to yield), then counter with 開 (kai - opening to issue). Build to free pushing, letting 開合 (kai he) guide all eight methods naturally.
5. **Tips**: Use mirrors or video for feedback; coordinate with reverse abdominal breathing (逆腹式呼吸 - ni fu shi hu xi) for deeper qi activation. Practice 20-30 minutes daily, progressing from isolated drills to dynamic flow. Seek a qualified teacher for corrections.
This reductionist view elevates Tai Chi from techniques to profound internal art, fostering health, martial skill, and mindfulness. If you have a specific style or master in mind, I can refine this further!
沒有留言:
張貼留言