For these two exercises, I would watch the instant the direction changes. In Form 5, Backward Lean and Turn(仰轉), can you come out of the spiral smoothly while you are still inclined? In Form 6, Low Lateral Stance(下跨式), can you turn your chest toward the extended leg while the bent leg continues to support you? Those two moments reveal more about 中定 and 腰腿協調 than the depth of the final posture.
I checked the instructor’s Chinese transcript and written description. The player buffered at your exact 7:25 timestamp, so I can verify the sequence but cannot judge the demonstrator’s alignment in that particular frame. Video at 7:25
Form 5 · Backward Lean and Turn(仰轉)
The instructor describes three distinct actions. First, the chest and shoulders turn left with weight shared between the feet. Next, the upper body inclines back toward the right ankle as the right leg takes more weight. Then the right arm comes across the chest and accompanies a further turn. The 90° at 1:21 refers to the initial turn to the left. The video assigns no 90° target to the backward lean.
What I would add in teaching:
- Practice the transition into the lean(由轉入仰). On the first repetition, make the initial turn and pause before leaning. Notice the pressure under each foot. Then incline only a little and feel the right foot take more weight. This lets the student recognize when the supporting leg changes. If the head is already falling back before the student senses that change, make the arc smaller.
- Use the eyes to check the turn(眼隨身轉). The tape gives an advanced visual landmark: looking past the left shoulder toward the right toes. A student can gain the last few degrees simply by cranking the neck. Watch the breastbone(胸骨): if it has stopped turning while the chin keeps searching for the foot, finish the repetition there. This also makes 丹田帶動 more concrete. The change of direction involves the pelvis and rib cage, and the gaze follows.
- Test the return before adding depth(回轉自如). At a comfortable inclination, reverse the spiral a few degrees. Can the chest and pelvis begin coming back together, with the head following smoothly? If the student has to throw the head forward or swing the arm to get up, use a smaller range. This is how I would teach your point about 斜中寓正 here: the trunk is visibly inclined, and the practitioner still has a choice about the next movement.
Form 6 · Low Lateral Stance(下跨式)
The most easily missed instruction comes at 5:05–5:34. In the first direction, the right leg bears the weight(右腿坐實), the left leg extends sideways(左腿橫伸), and the right hand travels toward the left shin as the waist turns. The hand and chest therefore move toward one side while the main support remains on the other. That distinction is especially useful when teaching Snake Creeps Down(蛇身下勢).
| What to watch | What I would ask the student to feel |
|---|---|
| The right kua as the hand travels left(實胯與手的方向) | Pause when the right hand reaches the upper left shin. Can you still feel the right hip crease folded and the right foot supporting you? If reaching another inch makes your weight slide onto the left leg, that inch changes the exercise. |
| The bent knee during the turn(膝尖與腳尖同向) | Watch the right knee while the chest turns left. It may line up with the right toes at the beginning, then drift inward as the right hand crosses the body. A front view is useful for seeing exactly when that happens. |
| The reaching hand and shoulder(手隨腰轉) | At mid-shin, let the fingertips merely brush the leg. Can you pause and lift them slightly without losing the posture? If you need to pull on the shin, shorten the reach. This is a practical test of whether the legs and trunk are supporting the movement. |
| The change of sides(先起身,再換邊) | The tape specifically returns to the upright wide stance before reversing. Use that instant to feel both feet accept weight again. Rushing straight across at the lowest point removes this part of the exercise. |
For your own left knee, given the catching you’ve described, I’d practice the left-weighted side in a high frame(高架) and leave out the deep squat and chest-to-knee endpoint for now. You can still train the defining coordination: settle onto one leg, turn toward the other, and return under control. If the knee catches during the movement, stop that repetition. Deep knee bending and loaded pivoting are among the movements NHS musculoskeletal guidance advises reducing when meniscal symptoms are present. msk-bexley.nhs.uk
My English cue for the second exercise would be: “Sit into your right kua. Keep feeling the floor under your right foot as your waist carries your right hand toward your left shin. Stop where you can still come back smoothly.”
Let the weight-bearing knee bend generally in the direction its foot points(實腿屈膝,膝尖順著腳尖方向). A small, smooth inward arc can occur as the pelvis turns. I would allow that natural movement, but I would not teach students to deliberately draw the loaded knee inward(刻意扣膝). The instructor gives different cues for the two forms.
| Form | What to pay attention to |
|---|---|
| Form 5 · Backward Lean and Turn(仰轉), 1:36–1:55 | In the first direction, the tape says the left knee advances slightly toward the left toes. It then says the right knee bends and follows the body slightly leftward while the center of weight stays over the right foot. So yes, the weighted right knee may travel a little toward the center. The cue is to let it accompany the turn. The instruction about the knee’s vertical projection reaching the toes refers to the left knee. |
| Form 6 · Low Lateral Stance(下跨式), 5:26–5:52 | Here the instruction is explicit: 右膝開襠始終對準右腳尖. As you sit into the right leg and reach toward the left shin, the right knee continues to track in the direction of the right toes. Watch the instant the chest turns left. If the right knee follows the chest and caves inward, shorten the reach or use a higher stance. Apply the same principle on the other side. |
Biomechanically, where the knee travels and which way it points are different questions. The knee can move slightly toward the body’s center as the pelvis shifts, while still pointing generally along the foot. There is also some natural rotation within a bending knee. Tracking toward the middle of the foot is a useful visual guide, with some variation from stance width and foot angle. The available studies concern squats and other movements, so they do not establish an exact allowable angle for either Tai Chi form. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
For teaching, I’d put it this way: “In 仰轉, let the weighted knee follow the turn a little. In 下跨式, keep the weighted knee facing its own toes as the chest turns toward the other leg.” Video lesson
Yes, Peter, if the right foot stays planted and you deliberately pull the weight-bearing right knee inward to gain more turn, that can increase stress at the knee. My earlier cue, “let the weighted knee follow the turn,” was too broad. It could encourage exactly the movement you’re concerned about. A small inward movement by itself, however, does not tell us that injury is occurring. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
In Form 5(仰轉), the distinction is between the knee moving slightly left in space(膝隨身略向左移) and the knee caving inward under load(實膝內扣). The first describes the kneecap’s location. The second concerns the alignment of the thigh, knee, and planted foot. If your pelvis turns left and your knee moves a little with it, the knee may still bend generally in the direction of the right foot. If the right thigh rolls inward and the knee progressively points across the foot as you sink, you are adding a twist under load. Research supports using the middle of the foot as a practical tracking guide, although it gives no precise safe angle for this particular form. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
I would teach it this way: “Settle onto the right foot. Keep the right knee soft and bending generally toward the middle toes. Turn only as far as the hip and trunk comfortably allow. If you need to draw the knee inward to turn farther, make the turn smaller.” 右腳坐實,右膝順腳尖,鬆胯轉身;轉到膝要內扣時,就把幅度縮小。
Given the catching you’ve described in your left knee, I’d use a higher stance and a smaller turn when the left leg bears weight. If it catches during the movement, stop that repetition and mention the specific movement to your orthopedist or physical therapist. www.nhs.uk